Forum

Forum Rules

.

Please or Register to create posts and topics.

Brief update - End of my Vacation.

That sounds like an extremely naive idea

India and China have a significantly large power assymetry/imbalance of power

This means China holds plenty more cards than India and seen as being stronger than India in several aspects

Where there is power assymetry, there cannot be friendship or unlimited trust

The best outcome one can hope for is a ‘No Conflict, State of Caution' where mutual development remains unaffected

Question : How is there an imbalance between India and China

The Imbalance between India and China is substantiated everywhere and requires no exclusive source

India remains

  1. A Fifth the size of China in Economic Size
  2. A Twelfth the size of China in contribution to Global manufacturing
  3. A Ninth the size of China in terms of logistics and cargo
  4. A Fourth the size of China in gross foreign reserves
  5. A Fiftieth the size of China in net foreign reserves
  6. Additionally Technological capabilities, Industrial depth, High Quality St Talent, Manufacturing depth, Productivity are all areas where China has a lead that cannot be quantified on paper but is universally regarded as being more than substantial

Such an imbalance means China is capable of absorbing cost of war for several years while India might be unable to handle economic or military shocks beyond a year tops

Question : Why can India be more comfortable with the States than with China despite stronger power assymetry?

There is a safe distance between India and the States with no conflict overlap

The States is too far away and there are no conflicts - Boundary, Ideological or otherwise

Indians of five generations have grown up seeing the States as a Great Power & have enmeshed their finance systems, technology systems completely to the ones run by the States

The Political establishment in India has accepted the possible humiliation & heavy handedness by the States , as part of a price to pay for a ‘Close relationship with the States'

Question : Why can't India develop a similar relationship with China?

India can and India will

It would take time

Presently Indians of four generations have seen China as a counterpart of India, a poor country with a similar colonial background

It might take another 2 generations to acknowledge China differently at which stage, India would redefine the relationship

Singapore and Malaysia is an apt example

Malaysia continued to regard Singapore as a peer well into the 1990s and middle 2000s but by the 2010s began seeing Singapore as a far more prosperous technologically evolved country

The term is known as ‘Generational Familiarity’

Until such time - the best relationship possible would be one of

  1. Mutual Economic Cooperation
  2. Mutual co existence
  3. Low conflict
  4. Low interference in others affairs

My daughter died one month earlier...

Our reality can be strange.

Pictures

c3382cbf9cab7c9da47df5d0077bbd9e
c3382cbf9cab7c9da47df5d0077bbd9e

b02451c105cebb15499880cda744e74b
b02451c105cebb15499880cda744e74b

9ada9cd0e7ff6ad5baf155e477599270
9ada9cd0e7ff6ad5baf155e477599270

f4602c5f9dbaa2efb30b2851c7d82061
f4602c5f9dbaa2efb30b2851c7d82061

a46e73075bdc425d79a8c9c74ecd5369
a46e73075bdc425d79a8c9c74ecd5369

bdaf64928129be10cde3c063b11965aa
bdaf64928129be10cde3c063b11965aa

8a491ce57724260ff7fe5fac00572161
8a491ce57724260ff7fe5fac00572161

737d4cd8bea53a5bbdad65fd190e4bf8
737d4cd8bea53a5bbdad65fd190e4bf8

15aa7cc5e45f58e0565d3d726b9142cd
15aa7cc5e45f58e0565d3d726b9142cd

8de9acb04beaee76de63fd40d8406756
8de9acb04beaee76de63fd40d8406756

d7590cfeaf578834ef88e1c8ab9e36e4
d7590cfeaf578834ef88e1c8ab9e36e4

b91747df3b84d0e8a11c17ca60b0eaf3
b91747df3b84d0e8a11c17ca60b0eaf3

44b5bd88db4165d01764a4a1e4df6af7
44b5bd88db4165d01764a4a1e4df6af7

b29343f26e801e0f7aaecf228d5c2f78
b29343f26e801e0f7aaecf228d5c2f78

93fc5d46f161ec7d250e7fde99859e65
93fc5d46f161ec7d250e7fde99859e65

d1bdbb772c3528c6ff142f938aa23596
d1bdbb772c3528c6ff142f938aa23596

9231caf41820f322a64eaeaa8606792d
9231caf41820f322a64eaeaa8606792d

f9b5291cbfdab85c3c159001c74c7be4
f9b5291cbfdab85c3c159001c74c7be4

de2d555b25cbcc7100dca7a7426991c8
de2d555b25cbcc7100dca7a7426991c8

c4f784912938e07426a9d12f82e21178
c4f784912938e07426a9d12f82e21178

9e58090cf3e0fb73ebeca1e0242a5bdf
9e58090cf3e0fb73ebeca1e0242a5bdf

707704baea8b338105bdb23f8fea2a6d
707704baea8b338105bdb23f8fea2a6d

4f0f9060fb727bd9fb4929a3e2091b8d
4f0f9060fb727bd9fb4929a3e2091b8d

1ccd3a24a635ba30e805846aab31a4ee
1ccd3a24a635ba30e805846aab31a4ee

5a462f110f1c25169c4d957702e9295a
5a462f110f1c25169c4d957702e9295a

efb079292cb9b9d33e5d9bb45842ac7a
efb079292cb9b9d33e5d9bb45842ac7a

e0b6e9e8c088eecc3def7d6bde14f953
e0b6e9e8c088eecc3def7d6bde14f953

d654202ea2ad047d52bae722cf165705
d654202ea2ad047d52bae722cf165705

b4eedb7b466a5dc1bb14ffb8c19697c5
b4eedb7b466a5dc1bb14ffb8c19697c5

2d10950aab23487969e8cc411c9e153b
2d10950aab23487969e8cc411c9e153b

00accc090f22a4f153eca2ae8b3b07b3
00accc090f22a4f153eca2ae8b3b07b3

249a44fb8920cc31bf45f390c993e168
249a44fb8920cc31bf45f390c993e168

7ab0a0df0aa8324c9374185f9f7aaed1
7ab0a0df0aa8324c9374185f9f7aaed1

0fbb1cc895070f8aa5edb4c873c9fc01
0fbb1cc895070f8aa5edb4c873c9fc01

0b8f75faf17ebf5ca2b9fb0aa4715095
0b8f75faf17ebf5ca2b9fb0aa4715095

9a093b5381796f47dbed925ca2a3d68b
9a093b5381796f47dbed925ca2a3d68b

7867d4655ab2e92d026e0b0d8cc56e81
7867d4655ab2e92d026e0b0d8cc56e81

a393826a1bbe95a3380c167bc5ca0f37
a393826a1bbe95a3380c167bc5ca0f37

2d35595c5b72b01e2f40d6c770083593
2d35595c5b72b01e2f40d6c770083593

009040b085a10edd8bc6c604a618f76b
009040b085a10edd8bc6c604a618f76b

d1baf9dcdd39e69954684c93d0f9554e
d1baf9dcdd39e69954684c93d0f9554e

35e19d6185f3d1f5bd044a870a71db04
35e19d6185f3d1f5bd044a870a71db04

00d49cffd776b24131e8329080ab6bb2
00d49cffd776b24131e8329080ab6bb2

f2ab44f96733e28c274589dfd8516ecc
f2ab44f96733e28c274589dfd8516ecc

21df730c3807eaef6974a7ab87e898ac
21df730c3807eaef6974a7ab87e898ac

d97e4fba2105f71ebf149cb7821ce462
d97e4fba2105f71ebf149cb7821ce462

3c438882cd17a03783ad2e6d62ec2606
3c438882cd17a03783ad2e6d62ec2606

fa96e3195b20752e6e249a786e274c9a
fa96e3195b20752e6e249a786e274c9a

53b7867994965d5edf4ae49b85da141c
53b7867994965d5edf4ae49b85da141c

b791f8ebfd7869fd5b63147267fdfe84
b791f8ebfd7869fd5b63147267fdfe84

bd08415a622d296caaa0522edb1033cc
bd08415a622d296caaa0522edb1033cc

daa3a2ad4967196c3f79ecc8e60e466b
daa3a2ad4967196c3f79ecc8e60e466b

2a7b37c7ce4096a56bf0b04f901a0327
2a7b37c7ce4096a56bf0b04f901a0327

323699313493f4e6ca209ea00d33437d
323699313493f4e6ca209ea00d33437d

74c8fce756d05e665d8aa9e10bb9da12
74c8fce756d05e665d8aa9e10bb9da12

65fc9bbc1cb05193c71c37dc3f25abae
65fc9bbc1cb05193c71c37dc3f25abae

2f31652922d3488575c4d4aa33079e60
2f31652922d3488575c4d4aa33079e60

ffdad963d649ddc2a77ca78db642dcc1
ffdad963d649ddc2a77ca78db642dcc1

c3a68312b151dd8eb4ca25d210cb77e6
c3a68312b151dd8eb4ca25d210cb77e6

53ec53815b2f195eefc88213b2bda3c6
53ec53815b2f195eefc88213b2bda3c6

f3e8da9dc90b5b71cd10ff889fbddd7e
f3e8da9dc90b5b71cd10ff889fbddd7e

351267c342029cd0b4da7780f856da0c
351267c342029cd0b4da7780f856da0c

009a54445e8e22a6746e00aaa4993521
009a54445e8e22a6746e00aaa4993521

88e9e1a2c9051aa1e745dcb2d057b08d
88e9e1a2c9051aa1e745dcb2d057b08d

5bee2744ef838286f21e31173bda510d
5bee2744ef838286f21e31173bda510d

1c7d179bb1de050331a4c9a0f0a9a642
1c7d179bb1de050331a4c9a0f0a9a642

0b3aa54fe20673dae8c1dbb701cdf842
0b3aa54fe20673dae8c1dbb701cdf842

86c77c639249a155591ec02b491fa923
86c77c639249a155591ec02b491fa923

0e4b3b352118ea29d589336d8101ad76
0e4b3b352118ea29d589336d8101ad76

5266de0aef4b3f8fea48cf56ef1de29a
5266de0aef4b3f8fea48cf56ef1de29a

a971841c6385eff4bcce51b854fc60ec
a971841c6385eff4bcce51b854fc60ec

632d6d9d4aa0220736f85ca1af21964e
632d6d9d4aa0220736f85ca1af21964e

5a16dbee6ff666d51f51dd97a9e3f5a0
5a16dbee6ff666d51f51dd97a9e3f5a0

91464460d2a5e80f3adda796eccdddb2
91464460d2a5e80f3adda796eccdddb2

976b13367e2c6d1be354251d745cac9f
976b13367e2c6d1be354251d745cac9f

7c82a7705bde1abc23333fab905a684d
7c82a7705bde1abc23333fab905a684d

ff06ff2873a244096a0252be1c6bd775
ff06ff2873a244096a0252be1c6bd775

53a8faad868421e30fa59abe59474985
53a8faad868421e30fa59abe59474985

b677e7d794a9b1693a59774f879f6d9d
b677e7d794a9b1693a59774f879f6d9d

59ec08f75f4eff4ddcb61aed7105e745
59ec08f75f4eff4ddcb61aed7105e745

526dd5964fea7ba538a9892ee92ddd15
526dd5964fea7ba538a9892ee92ddd15

2b448fad48927b22cc161a12c6e909fe
2b448fad48927b22cc161a12c6e909fe

b7bedb08372638d2380ccc11d2474c44
b7bedb08372638d2380ccc11d2474c44

8e5fe4f26ca2f4707353fed3661a864b
8e5fe4f26ca2f4707353fed3661a864b

90dd80d5540a9023a185e08a8fadff36
90dd80d5540a9023a185e08a8fadff36

d77edb8b43a09c8a141191c59b6883eb
d77edb8b43a09c8a141191c59b6883eb

470b47f4b8ed419fbb7f4d3e4a91a8db
470b47f4b8ed419fbb7f4d3e4a91a8db

586258fc10428642050b167992e2425b
586258fc10428642050b167992e2425b

bdc7d03e0f1333787980da80bf4f6414
bdc7d03e0f1333787980da80bf4f6414

b4c170cbddeccddabae39cb3017e6892
b4c170cbddeccddabae39cb3017e6892

292966791333b8aba9fee8b4c81158d8
292966791333b8aba9fee8b4c81158d8

e7477d3345158a1f2688e87ba74bde60
e7477d3345158a1f2688e87ba74bde60

3453ee8490cc8f2c6c1ad93c8e217f57
3453ee8490cc8f2c6c1ad93c8e217f57

5160f24ec026cb7ef352afb1f90f794f
5160f24ec026cb7ef352afb1f90f794f

4380382c6c161c66787f7a2b07e31cf7
4380382c6c161c66787f7a2b07e31cf7

deb4cf9678f729e70ed84022f50637c4
deb4cf9678f729e70ed84022f50637c4

f49de0fe811ea1fd5a8f6c7dad0fc735
f49de0fe811ea1fd5a8f6c7dad0fc735

ab5c3367bb3a5716e6c08ae4dcc6c4dc
ab5c3367bb3a5716e6c08ae4dcc6c4dc

50cd9f1d18cf9f6a8061c28cf838b78c
50cd9f1d18cf9f6a8061c28cf838b78c

6be17e7978c06869b58b487d0d8faeca
6be17e7978c06869b58b487d0d8faeca

e790c4d5b1b8b557d0cfdeaee2d31d5f
e790c4d5b1b8b557d0cfdeaee2d31d5f

c7bc33b69e8f2eed38ca46ed498317da
c7bc33b69e8f2eed38ca46ed498317da

160bcfb5d25681aaf44985849d84a9b7
160bcfb5d25681aaf44985849d84a9b7

eff95508157ddcc70f266f026665aa2e
eff95508157ddcc70f266f026665aa2e

d061ed5056e0fd3bd4f57a574540d5d1
d061ed5056e0fd3bd4f57a574540d5d1

1f1c013af334ad7620f7b0660dbddfdb
1f1c013af334ad7620f7b0660dbddfdb

ff8a493866088955850c8c7e9cd4efd6
ff8a493866088955850c8c7e9cd4efd6

faddc811be572e8a18bdf4c31801899e
faddc811be572e8a18bdf4c31801899e

c36c51dd6b9c10ae4225d1b40f613c7d
c36c51dd6b9c10ae4225d1b40f613c7d

61ffb6c870f6541ec7a92989a70d8201
61ffb6c870f6541ec7a92989a70d8201

0b3163d1b8cd5ac81617d5dd09eef636
0b3163d1b8cd5ac81617d5dd09eef636

38b0ad8b57aaba1d9722236706e3fd4a
38b0ad8b57aaba1d9722236706e3fd4a

Electronic Warfare (EW) comes in a couple of varieties, electronic surveillance (ES) and electronic attack (EA).

When it comes to ES, there are a multitude of aircraft that perform this role. As a Navy guy, I’ll give the example of our premier platform, the P-8 Poseidon:

Take a close look at it. All it is is a Boeing 737 but there are a bunch of “appendages” sticking out. I truly have no idea what all of those antennas are for, nor would I tell you here on Quora if I did. The P-8 is first and foremost a sub hunter but there are varieties that can be outfitted with gear for ES. One of its predecessors, an EP-3, was involved in an international incident back in the early aughts with China. This was the infamous “spy plane brought down by the Chinese” incident. I have my feelings on what the mission commander did, but I’ll leave that for another time.

Now EA! That’s my bread and butter.

EA-18G Growler

It is so hard to accurately describe what we do. Big picture, we jam RADARs but what does “jam” actually mean? The tactics aren’t the same for every RADAR so it’s really a catch all term for what we do. Again, going big picture, I’ve co-opted the term stealth: we provide stealth to non-stealthy aircraft. IOW, we hide them by making a RADAR scope unusable. And we have a perfect record; no plane has ever been shot down by a SAM if they have Prowler/Growler support.

An F-16CJ has what they call a HARM Targeting System, HTS. These guys go out and intentionally get targeted so they can shoot a much faster HARM at the shooter. I love me some CJ action. But a Growler is the preeminent platform for EA. Not only can I jam a target and get a soft kill, but my systems are even better at locating a threat so we can opt for the hard kill. Even better, the HARM is a bygone relic at this point. Now we’re talking AARGM. I can’t over emphasize how much better it is compared to a HARM. In the Navy, we considered a HARM a soft kill weapon because it wasn’t terribly accurate and you couldn’t count on it hitting the target (we are VERY conservative in our estimates). AARGM is not just an upgrade to HARM. It’s a whole different beast and is truly amazing, no bias whatsoever on my part.

To sum up, electronic warfare is extremely complicated and extremely complicated to explain. One platform may be better at a specific task, but there are others that are better at something else. Whatever task you’re trying to accomplish, go Navy. We don’t f around and will dismantle your IADS (Integrated Air Defense Systems) with just a couple of aircraft.

Go ahead. Target one of my buddies. Light them up, just like we want you to do. Now run! My missile is faster than yours and has an energy advantage. Your site is about to blow up. Sayonara.

Shorpy

 

32246u.preview
32246u.preview

SHORPY 99390u.preview
SHORPY 99390u.preview

SHORPY 99455u.preview
SHORPY 99455u.preview

SHORPY 5a28888u.preview
SHORPY 5a28888u.preview

SHORPY 5a17215a.preview
SHORPY 5a17215a.preview

SHORPY 5a24440u.preview
SHORPY 5a24440u.preview

SHORPY 5a07352u.preview
SHORPY 5a07352u.preview

SHORPY 5a11356u.preview
SHORPY 5a11356u.preview

SHORPY 40266a.preview
SHORPY 40266a.preview

SHORPY 40237a.preview
SHORPY 40237a.preview

SHORPY 40294a.preview
SHORPY 40294a.preview

SHORPY 40381a.preview
SHORPY 40381a.preview

SHORPY 00353a.preview
SHORPY 00353a.preview

SHORPY 01678a1.preview
SHORPY 01678a1.preview

SHORPY 02457a.preview
SHORPY 02457a.preview

SHORPY 03031u.preview
SHORPY 03031u.preview

SHORPY 4a27597a.preview
SHORPY 4a27597a.preview

SHORPY P0150.preview
SHORPY P0150.preview

SHORPY 4a28844a.preview
SHORPY 4a28844a.preview

SHORPY 4a27592a.preview
SHORPY 4a27592a.preview

SHORPY 4a25073a.preview
SHORPY 4a25073a.preview

SHORPY 4a27265a.preview
SHORPY 4a27265a.preview

SHORPY 09695a4.preview
SHORPY 09695a4.preview

SHORPY 09648a.preview
SHORPY 09648a.preview

SHORPY 99386u.preview
SHORPY 99386u.preview

SHORPY 99387u.preview
SHORPY 99387u.preview

SHORPY 09467a.preview
SHORPY 09467a.preview

SHORPY 09465a.preview
SHORPY 09465a.preview

SHORPY 99536u.preview
SHORPY 99536u.preview

SHORPY 32422u2.preview
SHORPY 32422u2.preview

Col Douglas Macgregor DESTROYS Smug Indian Journalist on China & US Military Dependency

I was afraid to watch this, but it is really pretty good.